The rape allegation in opposition to Paul Haggis

The choose of preliminary investigations of the Brindisi court docket, Vilma Gilli, determined to increase the home arrest of director Paul Haggis, accused by an Englishwoman of sexual violence. In line with the investigating choose, there are actually the hazards of polluting proof and recidivism. However, he didn’t validate the arrest, after the questioning of assure, for hazard of escape.

Haggis, 69, Canadian but in addition a US citizen, Oscar winner in 2006 with beat (Greatest Image and Greatest Authentic Screenplay) had been arrested by order of the Brindisi prosecutor on June 19, after a 29-year-old Englishwoman accused him of sexual assault. The director was in Puglia to movie a promotional spot for the candidacy of the municipality of Mesagne because the capital of Italian tradition, and should have been one of many protagonists of Allora Fest, a competition that takes place in Ostuni from 22 to 26 June.

The truth that In 2017, in america, press secretary Haleigh Breest alleged that she was raped by Haggis after a preview of the movie in 2013. Since 2018, 4 different girls have additionally reported being victims of harassment and sexual assault by the director. Haggis has at all times denied the allegations, arguing that the relationships had been consensual. He additionally tried to sue Haleigh Breest in flip (the subpoena was rejected) for defamation, claiming he would attempt to extort $9 million from him.

Within the six pages wherein the investigating choose of Brindisi motivated the choice of home arrest is attributed to the director, as reported by the Corriere della Seraone “absolute lack of ability to manage their very own instincts and quit their intentions in an perspective of prevarication and domination”. The investigating choose made her determination motivating her with the danger that the girl “by means of contacts with Haggis or with third events could also be induced to recant”.

What is understood up to now concerning the case is that the director and the girl who accuses him of rape met in late April on the Munich movie competition. On this the variations coincide. The Englishwoman makes use of a pseudonym, a French identify, each in life and on social media. It is usually the identical identify, however there isn’t any affirmation of this, which Haggis would have recognized him by.

Haggis claimed throughout safety interrogation that he had invited the girl to affix him in Ostuni for the competition, which befell on June 12. The director spoke of a cohabitation that lasted three days and with two sexual relations. In line with the story the girl supplied to Deputy Lawyer Antonio Negro and Deputy Lawyer Livia Orlando, she arrived at Haggis in Puglia, making use of for the function of guide. Haggis would have met her at Brindisi airport and brought her to the farm the place she resided.

At that second, in response to the girl’s report, the primary violence occurred. From the summaries of the testimonies revealed within the newspapers, it appeared that the girl determined to not report it as a result of the director wished to he reassured himself of his intentions to determine a “romantic relationship” along with her. In entrance of the magistrates, the girl additionally mentioned that she was fascinated by the director and subsequently admired by him.

Later, the girl says, there can be two extra sexual assaults. In line with her testimony, there would have been a robust argument, after which the director would have taken her, at daybreak and really abruptly, to Brindisi airport in a rented automotive. At that second, the girl, “in a state of confusion”, as said within the police report, would have addressed a hostess after which the police, formalizing the criticism. Investigators made the preliminary checks and the girl underwent medical examinations which, in response to some newspaper reviews, confirmed the presence of accidents. Solely then did the prosecutor ask for the arrest of the Haggis, who denies the allegations.

In line with Michele Laforgia, the director’s lawyer, “Paul Haggis defined how issues occurred. He pleaded not responsible, as he had achieved in instant arrest. The relationships he had with this lady are completely consensual throughout these three days spent collectively in Ostuni ». The lawyer mentioned, after the questioning of assure earlier than the investigating choose: “We additionally make clear, opposite to what’s supposed within the accusations, that there isn’t any harm and no signal of violence”, contesting the interpretation of the medical report.

The prosecutor requested for an evidentiary incident to be held with a direct confrontation between the accuser and the accused. The evidentiary incident is a sort of anticipation of the method that serves to kind and purchase notably related proof with out having to attend for the trial, and is utilized in specific when there may be worry {that a} witness shall be induced to retract or change the model. . , when the appreciation of issues and other people is topic to “inevitable alterations” and even when “causes of urgency don’t permit us to attend till judgment”.

Instantly after Haggis’ arrest, many requested organizers to cancel the Ostuni competition. The organizers confirmed all of the appointments, asserting, nevertheless, that “they’ve instantly proceeded to get rid of any participation by director Paul Haggis from the occasion».

Leave a Comment